Tag: United Nations

  • Mongolia Update | April 1997

    Mongolia Update | April 1997

    Publisher: UNDP Mongolia Communications Office

    Published: April 1997

    This is an unofficial publication of UNDP. Views presented in this document do not necessarily reflect those of UNDP. Mongolia Update is provided as service to those who are interested in the rapid changes taking place in today’s Mongolia.

    General Update

    Economic and Social Update

    Partnership for Progress Update

    New Initiatives

    I. General Update 

    Presidential Elections

    This is the third time during a twelve month period that Mongols are going to cast their vote. This May 18 they will make a decision on who will be the second president of the country. There are currently 1.2 million citizens of Mongolia eligible to vote to elect the new president. 30 regional election committees have been set up in the 21 aimags and nine districts of the city of Ulaanbaatar. Three presidential nominees were officially recognized by the general election committee and have received their certificates. The three include the incumbent president P. Ochirbat who promises to concentrate on implementing demands of the society and population, J. Gombojav prioritizing restoration of discipline and order, poverty alleviation and unemployment, and N. Bagabandi stressing the issue of social justice.

    Spring Session of the Parliament

    The spring session of the Parliament commenced on April 5. Out of more than 90 bills awaiting parliamentary approval, 27 draft laws have been included in the session agenda. These include such important legislation as the package of laws on taxation, amendments to the law on the constitutional court (Tsets) and among others a number of laws related to social issues, on land privatization, media, foreign military presence and transit.

    During the four months of the Fall session, the Parliament approved 18 laws, introduced amendments to 34 laws and issued 47 resolutions. Among the laws passed were packages on housing privatization, social protection and the law on NGOs.

    Spring Fires

    The 386 spring fires of last year took the lives of 25 people and injured 61 others, affected 10.2 million hectares of land, 175 dwellings and 7,690 livestock. The total damage was estimated at MNT1,129.4 billion, including MNT1,128.4 billion in ecological and economic damage, MNT589 million in damage to the private and public property, and MNT372.1 million in direct expenditures for fire fighting.

    As for this year, to date in April , a total of 51 forest fires have been registered in the country. Currently only three fires in Huvsgul, Hentii and Bulgan provinces are still being fought. The commission issued an instruction to strengthen monitoring of contained fires that still are going underneath the earth’s surface and can break out at any time. The commission regularly receives photos from a US satellite and this helps spot fires at a stage early enough to alert and mobilize local communities.

    II. Economic and Social Update

    Inflation Developments

    Mongolia seems to be different from its Asian neighbors in that while in those countries the Lunar New Year means a shopping rush and sales, in Mongolia it is quite the opposite. In Mongolia small traders dictate the prices in a country highly dependent on imports of basic necessities. It is not surprising that traders who supply almost 60-70 per cent of imported foodstuffs want to squeeze as much money as possible out of thier customers. The state customs tax inspection reported that the volume of imports grew three fold over the weeks preceding the Lunar New Year.

    The consumer index grew up by 8.1% since last December, and 2.3% as of March. Prices on meat, milk, milk products, home utilities, clothing and footwear have increased. Economists attribute the price hike to the soaring exchange rate of the Togrog vis-a-vis the US Dollar. Since the beginning of the year, the average inflation rate was up 2.7%.

    In accordance with the March report of the State Statistical Office, average household income in the country in February was MNT60.8 thousand. On average, compared to the same period in 1995, household income increased by 14.1%. The average monthly monetary expenditures per household was MNT60.8 thousand. The composition of household expenditure in the capital city includes food expenses up to 55% compared to the same period in 1996. In rural areas expenses for food stuffs comprise 47.4% as compared to the same period in 1996. Food expenditure was mostly for purchasing flour, flour products, meat and meat products. In Ulaanbaatar the change in consumption is due to a small shift towards payments for services such as public transport. As for the rural areas, this shift can be attributed to non- food expenses such as investment in private production, services and purchases of clothing and fabrics.

    Exchange Rate Developments

    16 per cent devaluation of the national currency during two weeks of March, following the Lunar New Year celebrations, was possibly due to the distrust people have towards the banks and a desire to convert their savings into hard currency. The parallel market rate reached MNT960 vis-a-vis the US Dollar. The Bank of Mongolia did not intervene in the process attributing the situation to a surge in demand for hard currency following the long winter months of slow trading. Every spring there is a short period, when the exchange rate surges but not as high as this year. This year, during the first three weeks of March, the rate went up by 8 percent compared to 6% in 1994, 7% in 1995 and 2% in 1997. Last year the central bank spent $ 73 million to maintain the exchange rate at MNT 640.

    As of the end of March, official statistics showed a 19.7% increase in the exchange rate of the Togrog vis-a-vis the US Dollar against the beginning of 1997 and some 69.7% increase when compared to the same period last year.

    Monetary and Banking Developments

    The Debt Collection Service, established last September, is working on returning to the banks coffers MNT28 billion in debts considered bad and resulting from the issue of MNT17.4 billion in credits in cities and MNT8.2 billion in credits in rural areas over the last few years, without proper examination of the lenders’ financial credibility.

    The Service collected more than MNT700 million within four months of 1996 and plans to bring back another MNT10 billion this year. Recently the department started applying indirect pressure by publishing the names of individuals and companies heavily indebted to banks. Eventually, the plans are to sell the debt papers on the securities market.

    The Bank of Mongolia reported that at the end of February, total money supply reached MNT114.5 billion, that is 10.8% less than that reported at the beginning of the year and about 12% more than during the same period in 1996.

    In March savings increased by 6.4%. This was connected with a 19.4% or MNT4.7 billion increase in foreign currency savings. Individual savings dropped by 1.5% against February but the account balances of economic entities increased by 4%.

    Fiscal Developments

    For 1997, state budget revenues are projected at MNT158 billion and expenditure at MNT184 billion, with a deficit standing at MNT26 billion. It is planned that the deficit be maintained at 3.9% of the GDP with further curbing by MNT6 billion from the MNT30 billion deficit registered in 1996. The parliament added MNT16.4 billion to the banking sector reform and endorsed the government to issue MNT15 billion in government bonds to cover the state budget deficit. The finance minister announced that much attention will be given for promotion of small producers and promised, that foreign investment will be given more favorable conditions.

    At the end of February, state budget revenues reached MNT28.8 billion, expenditures MNT29 billion with the budget deficit standing at MNT0.2 billion.

    Projections for state budget revenues for the first two months of the year have been exceeded by MNT1.4 billion, or 6.2%. This resulted from actions taken by the Government during the last half of 1996 to ameliorate debt and tax collection, reforms in public administration and reduction of subsidies to economic entities to improve the structure of budget expenditures and stronger monitoring of state budget revenues and expenditures.

    Projections for state budget expenditure for the first two months of the year have not been reached with a shortfall of MNT4.7 billion, or 16.5%. This is explained, in part, by the shortfall in privatization earnings of MNT1.4 billion.

    The new package of nine laws on taxation was submitted for consideration in the Spring session of the Parliament. The Prime Minister emphasized the significance of the new tax reforms that would have a mid and long term positive impact on economic recovery and a healthy business environment providing assistance to manufacturers and consumers.

    Amendments were made to the income tax law of economic entities and organizations. The reason for making the amendment, according to the National Taxation Board, was that there are currently 30 thousand economic entities operating in the country out of which only 8 thousand actually pay income taxes. The income tax law on economic entities stipulates for a 15% tax on income up to MNT100 million and 40% for those with an income above MNT100 million. Medium-sized companies will receive better incentives under the new taxation system now being discussed by Parliament. In general, taxes will be reduced through expanding the taxpayers base. The present system of corporate taxation results in some companies underreporting their profits and evading taxes. The study revealed that only 71 large companies contribute 85 percent of the tax revenue.

    Excise taxes on alcohol, alcoholic beverages, and tobacco have been increased two-fold. This would have the long term effect of promotion of indigenous industries and reducing low quality imports. Excise tax law changes include excise on petrol, diesel fuel and imported cars. It is estimated that by imposing excise tax on imported vehicles more than MNT1100 million will be generated for the state budget.

    Regarding customs duties, all except duties on spirits, alcohol, tobacco, oil products will be eliminated effective May 1. There is currently MNT17,475 in revenue to the state budget from this source. The issue of offsetting the revenue lost as a result of the elimination of customs duties requires addressing through a nearly 30% saving of expenditures of the state budget.

    The Parliament set a 10% tax on annual incomes of between MNT0-576,000, a 20% income tax for incomes between MNT576,001-1.152 million, 40% tax for those with an annual income of more than MNT1,152,001. The percentage of income tax in rural areas, especially among herders with private livestock, will vary depending on the amount of income and the market price of the animal products. People with less than 150 head of livestock, old age pensioners and low- income families will be exempt from income tax.

    Nationwide Inventory of State Assets

    In mid- February, the State Property Committee launched a nationwide inventory of state assets. All state- owned assets across the country were registered anew and assessed. The main purpose of this exercise was to come up with a clear picture of state property thus facilitating the Government ‘s decision as to what is to be passed to local Government jurisdiction. A total of MNT 110 million was initially planned to be used for the inventory. For the first time a comprehensive computer database will be set up with all property and assets categorized under type, location and value.

    Industrial and Real Sector Activities

    Construction Sector

    The rise in construction activities of about 31.4% compared to the same period last year during the first three months of 1997, can be attributed to construction work done by joint Mongolian and foreign units. The number of incomplete buildings, most of them public, reached 321 due to a shortage of state budget investment in the sector. In 1993, the government had to halt construction and conserve 114 building and offer another 186 for sale. This did not bring the desired results. Now the government bears the burden of MNT30 million every year in maintenance costs of these incomplete structures. Since the MNT30 billion funding necessary to complete the construction is unavailable, they are slotted for sale to the private sector.

    Gross industrial production

    In the first three months of the year, industrial output declined by 4.8% and totaled MNT44.1 billion. A survey revealed that shortage of cash poses a major problem for about 60% of enterprises while 27.1% named high interest rates on bank credits. Another 13% of enterprises have problems with procuring raw materials and supplies.

    Production levels in the mining sector, including coal, metal ore and quarrying of stone. And in the manufacturing of beverages, wood and wood products, metal products and power increased. However, decreases in the production of such industrial products as forestry products, meat and meat products, and tanning and dressing of leather, were evident.

    The private sector accounted for 46% of the total industrial output.

    Agriculture

    The Ministry of Agriculture is concerned about the potential shortage of seeds for grain farming in 1997. Though the country’s capacity to store seed reserves is 50 thousand tons, for the last few years only 5 to 8 thousand tons of seed were kept because of a shortage of money to finance reserve stocks . This year only 5 thousand tons of seed were reserved, but, according to preliminary estimates, for the 1997 sowing season the requirement will be 70 thousand tons of grain seeds to cultivate an area of 350 thousand hectares.

    Although the Ministry of Agriculture and Industry planned to cultivate more than 320,000 hectares of land this year, only 270,000 will be sown. The problem of grain seeds was solved to a degree with 6,800 tons of seeds coming from the state special reserve. A shortage of funds did not allow the agriculture companies to procure spare parts and only 70% of machinery is ready for spring work. Out of MNT 3.3 billion necessary for the sowing season, the agricultural farms plan to invest MNT 1 billion on their own, with another one billion coming from the flour mills as credits. The government refrained from issuing credits as before, and limited tax reduction on revenues by 50 percent. Despite the government appeal, commercial banks came up with only about MNT 300 million in credits.

    Responding to the Government’s request for assistance in emergency seed supply for the 1997 growing season, through its Emergency Production of High Quality Elite Seed and New Variety Testing project UNDP will assist Mongolia’s private sector farmers by i) re-starting the multiplication of high quality wheat seed by private enterprises on a pilot scale, and ii) testing new high quality wheat varieties under Mongolian’s agro-ecological conditions. This project will be a critical lead-in to future interventions by donor agencies and the private sector. The Special Relief Operations Service (TCOR), FAO, have fielded a seed specialist and a procurement officer to Kazakhstan to check and procure 200 tons of elite wheat seed. At the same time, new high yield wheat varieties are being procured in countries with overlapping agro-ecological conditions. Six new varieties of wheat seed are being shipped from Mexico and others from Canada.

    Foreign Trade Developments

    The total reported trade volume in the first three months of 1996 reached US$ 149.7 million showing a decrease of 21.7% over the same period in 1996. Exports totaled US$79 million and imports US$70.7 million. Exports were down by 20.9%, and imports down by 22.7%.

    The decrease in exports was caused by the fact that overall volume and prices for exported goods fell. Both price and volume changes affected such main export commodities as copper concentrate, fluorite spar concentrate, scoured goat down and hides. In the first quarter of 1997, the average border price of these commodities, which represent 71.3 % of export goods, was down by 14.5 % against the same period last year. This has led to a loss of US$11.6 million in export earnings in the first quarter, or US$12.2 as compared to the same period in 1996.

    The decrease in imports can be attributed to the fall in imports of main commodities such as fuel, oil and metal products.

    Exports to other countries, except the neighboring, increased. Imports from developed countries increased by 9.1 points against the same period last year, while imports from other countries decreased.

    Some 47.3 % of exports went to Switzerland, one of the top export destinations in 1996, 19.2 % to China, 10.9 % to Russia, 5.1 % to UK, 4.9 % to Italy. 39.7 % of imports were from Russia, the bulk of this volume being petroleum products, 8.3 % from the United States, 6.8 % from China, 5.1 % from Denmark and 4.1 % from Japan.

    Privatization

    The third attempt to privatize the 35-year old State Department Store (SDS) at the opening price of MNT3.4 billion is at standstill due to lack of bidders.

    The law on housing privatization was passed in mid-October 1996 and seeks to privatize more than two million square meters or MNT256 billion worth of state-owned apartments and was supposed to go into effect from January 1, 1997. However, it was vetoed by the President who considered that the law needed a further review due to contradictions with the Housing and other laws. The Law was finally passed in February this year. Under the Law, MNT260 billion worth 4,300,000 square meters of state-owned housing will be transferred into private ownership free of charge. Presently about 2.3 million people live in state-owned apartments. The above Law has provisions for exemption from privatization charges for female pensioners over 55 and male pensioners over 60, the rightful children-owners and orphans, individuals receiving allowances for disabilities, families having over 4 children aged 16 and below, low income single mothers with over 4 children aged 16 and below. The basic cost for a square meter was determined by the Parliament to be MNT150,000 (equivalent of approx. $190). Privatization of housing will start as soon as the government approves about 10 procedures prepared by the Ministry of Infrastructure Development. Most of privatized housing is concentrated in the capital city, and the condition and market value of about 60,000 flats will be assessed by experts.

    More residents of the capital city prefer to live in their own houses. Last year alone, 1,800 families out of 2,400, who moved into new houses, have become the owners of private cottages with 56,000 square meters of total living space. In 1996, more than 20,000 applications for a land patch permit were sent to the city council and twice more are expected this year. Presently, nearly 60% of the city’s 580,000 population live in ghers, a traditional felt-walled dwelling.

    In the course of privatization in 1991 – 1992, about 270 state owned farms and cooperatives were split into 2,000 smaller private units short of funds and equipment necessary to maintain cultivation at 450,000 hectares of arable land. Last week the government approved the auction of seven major agriculture companies and the trade the state owned shares of another 45 shareholding companies. Given the persisting decline of agriculture production and the deep crisis in the sector, the government faces the necessity to undertake resolute steps to solve the problems.

    Social Issues

    Unemployment

    Official statistics quote 57.5 thousand unemployed people registered at labor exchanges as of the end February. This figure is 11.1 thousand more than that in the same period of 1996.

    Poverty

    Official statistics show that the number of poor in the country is 446 thousand comprising some 103.5 thousand households. The poverty level is thus 19.4% of the population. The statistics are based on calculations of average monthly income per member of the household and vary from the 1995 survey conducted with the IBRD during which the calculations were made on the basis of average monthly consumption per member of household. Out of the total poor, nationwide there are 61,8 thousand people who are neither employed nor in school.

    The minimum subsistence level has been revised nine times since 1991. The last revision was made in February this year and included stipulations for regions of Mongolia. The poverty line now stands at MNT10,400 for Ulaanbaatar, MNT10,380 for Orkhon-Uul and Darkhan-Uul, MNT9,720 for the Western region, MNT 9,420 for the Middle region, MNT9,340 for the Gobi region, and MNT9,250 for the Eastern region. Another revision of the minimum subsistence level and minimum hourly wage is pending discussion at the Spring session of the Parliament to reflect correctly the inflation rate.

    The provisional committee against poverty representing about a dozen NGOs started a hunger strike on April 1 demanding to address the problem of aggravating poverty. On April 10, the Prime Minister met with the protesters and explained that the government inherited the problem of more than 103,000 pensioners and 87,000 unemployed and has not been able to address their problem within the few months in office. He instructed the Minister ofHealth and Welfare, as well as the City Mayor to see how to help them. The mayor promised the strikers jobs, bank loans and land to grow vegetables. As a result of this, the hunger strike was called off.

    Health

    The salaries of 32,000 health sector employees will be raised in the next three months irrespective of the civil servants’ fixed salary system. This decision follows the nationwide, 18,000 strong warning strike of the health sector employees held on February 28. Figures are quoted that presently 80% of doctors and nurses live in poverty.

    The newly amended law on health insurance became effective on April 1 evoking different reactions from patients, who are now to be charged for medical treatment. Payment for several categories of medical services, including MNT 1,100 for an ambulance call, MNT 3,000 for a blood test, and about MNT 10,000 for comprehensive medical examinations, as well as MNT 2,500 for each day in hospital for those without health insurance, were introduced.

    Since the adoption of the new law, the number of patients undergoing medical treatment decreased and vulnerable groups were most affected by this change. Upon popular demand, the Ministry of Health and Social Welfare is amending two attachments to the law on health insurance which state the costs of medical services.

    Work time reduction

    The 340,000 strong army of civil servants may switch into five working days a week schedule, if the parliament agrees with it at its spring session. The government had approved in principle the respective draft law and submitted it to the Ikh Hural. Under the bill, work time should not exceed 40 hours a week and annual holidays will be curtailed from 24 to 15 days. The government plans to introduce the shift without additional expenses from the state budget.

    III. Partnership for Progress Update – UNDP Activities in Mongolia

    The United Nations Development Programme has been a supporter of Mongolia’s development efforts since the 1970s. A new five year cycle entitled the Partnership for Progress which covers the period from 1997 to 2001 has began. The UNDP activities support the Mongolian Government’s Programme of Action (November, 1996), with its priority on economic growth under difficult transition conditions.

    The impact of Mongolia’s dramatic transition process in the 1990s makes economic growth a precondition for solving problems, especially those related to poverty. The successful implementation of the different parts of the Government’s Programme of Action is expected to generate growth. There are favorable conditions for Mongolia’s economic growth, including considerable natural resources, a literate human resource base, and growth oriented Government policies. However, significant obstacles exist including a limited infrastructure, growing poverty, a weak banking system, harsh climatic conditions and a vast territory.

    UNDP’s contribution to growth with equity will be three-fold. First, UNDP interventions will fully support the Government’s Programme to stimulate equitable economic growth. Second, UNDP, through its partnership role in the national poverty programme and natural resource management, will help the Government deal with various issues of people centered sustainable development. Third, UNDP will contribute significantly to the national capacity to formulate policy and to implement programmes which support sustainable human development by concentrating on strengthening governance capacities of the national government, local authorities and civil society.

    The UNDP supported activities attempt to bring together a multitude of partners in support of sustainable human development: Government authorities at the national and local level, civil society and NGOs, UNDP and the UN System, academia and the private sector, and bilateral and multilateral donors. The design of the Partnership for Progress combines global thinking with local actions to achieve and improve the well- being of the Mongolian people.

    In March, the Country Cooperation Framework 1997- 2001 for Mongolia was approved by UNDP Headquarters.

    Poverty Alleviation

    The composition of the National Poverty Alleviation Committee (NPAC) was revised to include the Prime Minister as the Chair of the NPAC, the Minister of Health and Social Protection as the Deputy Chair of the NPAC, and the Minister of Education, State Secretaries of the Ministries of Finance, Agriculture and Industry, Infrastructure Development, and Department heads of two Departments of the Ministry of Health and Social Protection, as members of the NPAC.

    The Targeted Assistance Fund (TAF) under the National Poverty Alleviation Programme is designed to provide in-kind assistance to the poorest members of society to help them meet their basic needs. TAF financial resources of $128,000 were distributed through Aimag Poverty Alleviation Councils (APACs)/District Poverty Alleviation Councils (DPACs). Since January 1997, a total of 523 projects were funded from the Local Development Fund which and Women’s Development Fund focused on health, education, vulnerable group income generation, and public works.

    Provision of Energy Efficient Social Services

    UNDP is giving importance to introducing and expanding renewable energy in the social infrastructure sector as relevant to the National Poverty Alleviation Programme and other social development activities. A project titled Provision of Energy Efficient Social Services was signed by the Government and UNDP in April. Within the framework of this project, 100 community centers will be constructed or refurbished, using the straw-bale technique, during the next 3 years. The project will have a direct impact on the health and education of a large number of children, women, new borns and clinic users in general. The demonstration concepts to be used can have large scale replication, reducing the energy needs and improving the living conditions of the poorest segments of the Mongolian population as well as providing unemployed people with skills for improved income.

    Poverty Newsletter

    The first issue of the Cheerful Poor, the latest arrival to the print media, has hit the news stand in April. The bi-weekly newspaper is being published by the National Poverty Alleviation Programme. The newspaper will inform the general public of the progress of the NPAP, statistics, job vacancies and other information for unemployed.

    Environment

    The new edition of the Mongolia Red Data Book on endangered and threatened species of Mongolia is being prepared with the direct involvement of the Mongolia Biodiversity Project. The Red Data Book will include globally and/or nationally endangered threatened plants and animals with maps and pictures showing their distribution. The National Fund for Endangered species and the British Government are contributing US$ 4,500 and £ 10,000 respectively for the printing of the book.

    A new grant from UNDP to the Environmental Public Awareness Programme will support public awareness projects proposed by national NGOs. It will allow the Programme to run more training workshops for project personnel and to travel throughout the country to monitor communities and NGOs, rural projects. The UNDP grant supplements the initial allocation from the Government of the Netherlands.

    Governance and Economic Transition

    Following the recommendations of the evaluation mission that took place in October 1996 the Government of Mongolia has by Prime Minister’s decree decentralized projects under the programme to Ministries.

    UNDP is presently in the process of designing the next three years projects that will support the government’s policies on good governance and successful economic transition. Among the many new proposals are the following: 1) project in support of Democracy and Local Self Governance, which will play an important role in consolidating UNDP’s support to aimag, soum and bagh communities; 2) project on support to Journalism, which through the Mongolian Press Institute will support a lively and professional national public debate; 3) second phase of the project on creation of a Public Management Information system, which will result in expansion by July 1997 of the established network between Prime Minister’s Office, Parliament Secretariat, President’s Office, Ministry of Finance, State Statistical Office and Tuv Aimag Center; 4) “Think Tank” project design, which will provide the highest political level with a financial support to quick national and international advice and research on relevant political responses to the complex economic and political transition process Mongolia is undertaking.

    HIV/AIDS/STD

    While Mongolia has been fortunate enough to have remained relatively free from HIV/AIDS in the past, changing economic conditions and associated lifestyles make Mongolia increasingly vulnerable to the ever growing worldwide HIV/AIDS pandemic.

    The United Nations system in Mongolia, at the request of the Government, has recently completed a two week assessment of the STDs and HIV/AIDS situation in the country, making recommendations and suggestions for national programmes and future international support and technical assistance. The challenge, as spelled out in their report “Working Together for a Safer World” is to develop an expanded national response involving all sectors of society, building upon the lessons learned during nearly two decades of working with the AIDS epidemic. The UNAIDS team, composed of representatives of UNICEF, UNDP, WHO and public health officials from Thailand and Vietnam, recommended four strategic activities for Mongolia:

    • establish effective national HIV/AIDS/STD policies and programme structures,
    • including strategic planning and coordination;
    • develop population targeted and pre-tested HIV/AIDS and STD information, education, and communication activities which facilitate safer behavior;
    • ensure the availability and promote the use of high quality condoms and
    • improve the quality of STD prevention and care.

    Aid Coordination

    The Government of Mongolia addressed the issue of aid coordination through the establishment of an Aid Coordination Unit (ACU) under the Prime Minister’s Office in September 1996. The Government’s Programme of Action stipulates that foreign grants and loans should be acquired from as many sources as possible with the aim of providing for the national and economic security of Mongolia and reducing the burden on the state budget.

    A draft law on amendments to the law on government was submitted for the consideration of the Spring session of the Parliament. The draft envisages the transfer of the coordination function of foreign aid, currently under the Ministry of External Relations, to the Ministry of Finance. Thus, the Ministry of Finance will have under its wing, issues pertaining to both loans and aid.

    A mission of an expert in external cooperation coordination is in town. The expert is working on a project proposal for assisting capacity building in aid coordination which will include the formulation of a resource mobilization strategy and technical assistance strategy.

    IV. New Initiatives

    Regional Economic Development

    The current territorial and administrative structure hinders steady development nationwide. To redressthis situation, the government has elaborated a new project on territorial zones of the country that envisages five major regions across Mongolia to facilitate adequate conditions for sustainable development of these areas. The project, already submitted to the Parliament, proposes to make Hovd, Uliastai, Arvaiheer, Ulaanbaatar and Choibalsan the centers of these zones taking into account the history of the nation’s development, specifics of demography, land, livestock, pastures, farming, mineral resources and other criteria. It also suggests having 18 aimags instead of the present 21, 91 groups of urban settlements and 334 soums. According to its classifications, cities should have a population of no less than 250 thousand, big towns some 50-250 thousand people, while settlements with a population of 30-50 thousand will be named small towns. The rest will be considered as urban and rural villages. The forecast for 2010 is that there will be one city, four big towns, 16 small towns, 43 urban and 312 rural villages in Mongolia.

    Foreign Direct Investment Forum, June 4-5

    During the Foreign Direct Investment Forum, co- sponsored by the Government and the World Bank, domestic and foreign businessmen and investors discussed joint exploration for oil, gold and zinc resources of the country.

    A trade fair will be sponsored by the Government and the World Bank to promote foreign investment and is expected to attract over 100 foreign firms and manufacturers.

    The government Foreign Investment Board expects MNT 160 billion investment this year. Last year, 180 companies and business entities from 28 countries applied to set up joint ventures in this country pledging a total of $39 million, in investment. Presently 20,000 Mongolians are employed in about 400 joint ventures.

    During the FDI Round Table meeting in October 1996, the government committed itself to following up on its recommendations and introducing changes to the Foreign Investment law adopted in 1993.

    Micro Credit Development

    Priority number one of the new Government, which came into power after the June elections 1996, is to increase employment and opportunities in order to develop sustainable economic growth. One of the potential opportunities for achieving this is the creation of micro credit facilities which in a country like Mongolia, with a small population and vast territory, could be later replicated at nationwide level. However, the current situation in the commercial banking sector does not allow for the development of such new credit facilities. The deep crisis situation that has occurred in the sphere of banking has made the resolution of the banking sector problem one of the burning issues of the economy. A number of commercial banks have fallen into deep financial crisis and effectively stopped playing the role of financial mediators in the economy.

    The Micro Credit Summit, held this February in Washington D.C., was attended by five participants from Mongolia. The purpose of the Summit was to launch a global movement to reach 100 million of the world’s poorest families, especially the women of those families, with credit for self- employment and other financial and business services, by the year 2005. Mongolia was included in the list of recipients of $ 21 billion to be allocated for 100 million impoverished people in developing countries. Heads and high level officials from 112 countries attended the Summit to discuss the future of microfinancing schemes in addressing development and poverty issues.

    Mongolia’s participants to the Summit are unanimous in their desire to convene a National Micro Credit Summit/ Workshop in late June to discuss and make policy recommendations for the development of micro credit in the country.

    The Ministry of Finance approved 120 small projects to be financed from the Soum Development Fund set up last year by the government. Up to MNT 5 million will be allocated from the fund to boost local economies in the country’s 334 soums (principalities). So far, 72 soums submitted 288 projects ranging from a shoe repair shop to a flour mill.

    Others

    UNICEF approved an $ 8.25 million budget for its operations in Mongolia. Under the Master Plan of Operations for 1997 – 2001, mother and child health protection, vaccination of children and the promotion of local community initiatives will be emphasized. UNICEF started its operations in Mongolia in 1984 and is an active promoter of child health protection issues.

    The World Bank announced a $35 million open tender for the modernization of the Baganuur coal mine. Caterpillar of USA, Comatsu of Japan and Volvo of Sweden are bidding for the right to supply bulldozers and heavy trucks. Japan recently allocated $48 million for the Shivee Ovoo coal mine modernization as well. When both projects are completed by the year 2005, the two mines will double their production to 10 million tons of coal a year.

    The Asian Development Bank signed an agreement with the Mongolian government on $60 million credits for 1997. About $40 million will be spent on modernization of the capital city heating and energy network and $15 million for the health sector reform. The remaining $5 million will be for the development of public service facilities in the Western provinces. Over the last years, AsDB has provided Mongolia with a total of 314 million in credits and another $ 31 million in technical assistance.

    The UNESCO Mass Communication Development Commission approved a $27,000 grant to the Press Institute of Mongolia to purchase a broadcasting studio. Set up a year ago with $1.2 million grant from the Danish government, the Mongolian Press Institute has received over last few months $30,000 from the UNDP to start an independent news agency based on Internet resources and another grant from the Soros Foundation to open a journalism school. As well as organizing seminars and courses, the Institute has opened a press conference center for Mongolian journalists. Another UNDP project focussing on training journalists in strategies to address their changing role will begin in mid 1997.

    The European Union plans to spend total of $19.5 million in technical assistance for Mongolia in the next three years. An additional $183,000 aid from the EU will be provided to alleviate the consequences of multiple fires last spring.

    A US$ 18 million road construction project to be financed under an agreement between the Ministry of Infrastructure Development and Arab Development Foundation of Kuwait is to be launched soon. A contractor to build an 180 km road between the second and third largest cities, Darhan and Erdenet, will be chosen from among the international companies short listed to bid.

    The first step towards unifying the efforts of more than 600 non-government organizations was made in April. About 20 NGOs including the Women’s Federation, Red Cross, Center for Children and Center Against Domestic Violence, agreed to set up a club named “Crossroads”, which will coordinate the activities of the member organizations, supply information and organize training. This center will serve as a focal point of joint actions. The club is a non-partisan body and will help influence the decision makers. Over the last few years, NGOs have flourished in this country with more than 600 of them registered at the Ministry of Justice. Last fall, Parliament approved the law on NGOs, which provides more incentives for public organizations.

    Solar Eclipse

    As astronomers had predicted, at 8.45, Sunday morning of March 9, one third of Mongolia sank into darkness as the sun disk went black for two minutes. Only the sounds of dogs barking and the banging of pots could be heard as people tried to scare away the Rahu Monster which, according to legends, swallows the sun. Long expected and speculated this natural phenomena did not stir much public attention and the capital city residents took it very quietly. More than 2,000 visitors were expected to view the solar eclipse from the Mongolian steppes. However, the number of foreign observers was a little over 1,000.

    Creative Commons License

    This work is licensed under a
    Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.

    ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5311-1052.

    © David South Consulting 2026

  • Mongolia Update | November 1998

    Mongolia Update | November 1998

    Editor and Writer: David South

    Researcher: G. Enkhtungalug

    Layout: U. Byambajargal

    Publisher: UNDP Mongolia Communications Office

    Published: November 1998

    This is an unofficial publication of UNDP. Views presented in this document do not necessarily reflect those of UNDP. Mongolia Update is provided as service to those who are interested in the rapid changes taking place in today’s Mongolia.

    A year of change

    Political changes

    The economy

    Agriculture

    Privatization

    Social issues

    Human Development

    Environmental and Natural Resources

    Management

    Governance and Economic Transition

    Mongolia began to turn the corner in 1997 as market reforms started to bear fruit. During the turbulent transition period of the early 1990s, Mongolians witnessed soaring inflation and a generally weak economy. This was the result of the transition period following the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end to subsidies and trading arrangements of that era. With the election of Mongolia’s first non-communist government in June 1996, the Democratic Union Coalition used its strong mandate to press ahead with accelerated market reforms while building on the foundation put in place by the reformed communists prior to 1996.

    The new government’s action programme was founded on fundamental economic reform, including privatisation of major industrial enterprises and state-owned banks, liberalisation of prices and the abolition of tariffs.

    According to the government of Mongolia the main objectives of Mongolia’s economic and social development in 1997 were fulfilled. In 1997 the most obvious successes were in the macroeconomic realm and in the emerging service sector. Inflation in 1997 was decreased first by 35 per cent and then by 17 per cent (it had reached 300 per cent during the 1990s) with a 31.1 per cent rise in economic growth . The GDP increased by 3.3 per cent against that of 1996. A budding service sector was already beginning to show its face on the streets of Ulaanbaatar. New shops, restaurants and bars were not just catering to the well-heeled foreign community but to the growing number of Mongolians with disposable income and an appetite for consumables. The number and quality of vehicles on the roads was also evidence of a consumer boom after years of pent up demand (there were 65 020 registered vehicles in 1996 and 70 088 in 1997). .

    The 1997 state budget revenue of Mongolia totalled Tg 227.6 billion and state budget expenditures reached Tg 289 billion. Expenditures exceeded income by Tg 70.4 billion. Industrial production increased by 4.4 per cent against 1996. A source of pride for a traditionally nomadic country, the livestock population reached a historic high in 1997 with 31.3 million heads, up 2 million from 1996.

    Privatization of state entities continued apace in 1997 with apartments being sold by the state to occupants; in a surprise move the government decided to give away apartments for free to those who had lived in them prior to October 1996. The State Property Committee’s goal for 1998 is to finish privatization of all small state entities which now total 500.

    Oil Prospects Brighten

    Prospects for increasing government revenues from oil extraction brightened in 1997. On June 6 in Dornod aimag 700 barrels of high quality petroleum were extracted from a 2 400 meter well. Four wells out of the six tapped had petroleum and it is believed that the region will have an abundant reserve for several years. Estimates by a Swiss bank and the American Soco Company place the deposit at 15 million barrels of high quality oil with the potential to deliver 700 barrels per day. Twenty wells are expected to be drilled up by 1999.

    Flash floods killed 13 people and over 5 000 animals, and destroyed over 13 dwellings in Galuut, Bayan-Ovoo and Ulziit sums of Bayankhongor aimag on June 23. The total damage was estimated to be Tg 164.2 million. The MIAT Yu-12 plane crash in the spring(???) in Dundgobi, killed eight and seriously injured four people.

    Despite some improvements in the economy, high levels of unemployment and consequently, a perceptible increase in poverty ( not to mention a slow economic recovery outside the capital ) took its toll on the political realm. Support for the opposition MPRP remained strong and cracks were beginning to appear in the Coalition government.

    In the political arena, MPRP candidate for the presidential office, N. Bagabandi, received 60.8 per cent of the vote in a May 18 election, in a campaign stressing social justice. International observers called the election free and just and on June 20 the newly elected President of Mongolia took office. At the start of the academic year in September, students from state-owned colleges and universities, led by the Mongolian Students’ Union, went on strike. They demanded a reversal of tuition fee and dormitory charge hikes. After meeting with student leaders, the government acceded to their demands, instructing university directors to cut fees and slash dormitory rents. But with no commitment of extra money from the government, university administrators warned cuts would have to be made in other areas, including supplies and instructors’ salaries. It was the first-ever attempt by public university students to go on strike.

    MPRP Clash with Coalition

    With the opening of Parliament on October 1 the government was challenged by a more confident opposition led by the MPRP, newly invigorated by the election of its candidate for President. The leader of the MPRP, N.Enkhbayar, took office and chose the opening session of Parliament to call for the government’s resignation. He accused the Coalition of ignoring its election promise to cut taxes by 20 to 30 per cent, of bungling privatisation and neglecting the social sphere. Finally, on October 17 the government marshalled its majority in a secret ballot to defeat the resolution, with 47 MPs voting against and 25 for. Prime Minister M. Enkhsaikhan used the occasion to defend his government’s record, noting that inflation had been decreased, the tugrug stabilized, foreign currency reserves increased and a banking crisis deflected.

    A mayoral decree issued in July called for all Ulaanbaatar residents between the ages of 15 to 40 years to undergo compulsory testing for HIV/AIDS and other Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs) during a campaign slated for the first two weeks of October. The supervisor in charge of the city’s health office, Mr. Y. Terbish, then said that only females in this “high-risk” age group were to be tested. Finally, the Ministry of Health ascertained that the campaign was to be carried out in all aimags and non compulsory.

    According to the STD/AIDS Prevention Center director Mr. H.Davaajav, about 84 per cent of the Ulaanbaatar population between the ages of 15 to 40 underwent voluntary testing; 1,036 were infected with STDs, whereas 300 tested negative for HIV.

    Prime Minsiter M. Enkhsaikhan was forced to call an emergency Cabinet meeting in December when it was discovered that one of two men from Cameroon – previously arrested for fraud – had tested positive for HIV, gonorrhoea and trichomonas while in prison. The two men became a media cause celebre, and were later deported from Mongolia. A police investigation revealed that the two men had had sexual relations with four Ulaanbaatar sex workers, who in turn had sex with 56 Mongolian men. One of the women tested positive for HIVs, making her’s the second known case in Mongolia. The first HIV case to be identified in Mongolia was reported in 1992.

    January 1998

    ¨ The new year brought more than just hangovers for Mongolians; it also brought a shorter work week. Since the early days of communism Mongolians had grown used to a six-day work week. This changed when the Parliament amended the labour law to switch to a five-day work week as of January 1. Despite prophecies of doom from some quarters, the transition to a shorter work week passed quietly. Though compulsory holiday time was shortened to 14 days from three weeks, wages stayed the same. According to a Parliament poll, 72 per cent of the population supported the change.

    ¨ The government’s Year of Youth also kicked off the new year with its own song sung by Mongolia’s top pop musicians. Tg 150 million will be spent on activities planned for the year, including concerts and a summer youth forum. According to the State Statistical Office, 64 per cent of the population is between the ages of 16 and 35. Youth have been hit hard by the economic changes, with 62.5 per cent of the unemployed under 35. Secondary and higher education enrolment reached 116,300, with 57.6 per cent female and 42.4 male.

    ¨ The Ministry of Health and Social Welfare and the Young Leaders’ Club jointly established the National Foundation Against AIDS. The Foundation will organize peer counselling, testing and advice for young couples.

    ¨ The Mongolian Nature Protection Association has become an official member of the International Confederation of World Nature Protection Associations.

    ¨ Mongolia’s livestock population topped 31.3 million heads according to the SSO. This broke down into 355,100 camels, 2.9 million horses, 3.6 million cows, 14.1 million sheep and 10.3 million goats. The decline in the camel population in 14 aimags is of concern.

    ¨ The Democratic Coalition defended its record to date, claiming it had fulfilled one third of its Contract with the Voters. Since being elected in 1996, the government had passed 189 laws, rescinded 13 and issued 183 decrees.

    ¨ A Cameroonian national infected with AIDS was deported from Mongolia on January 7.

    February 1998

    ¨ Satoma-Oil, a Mongolian and American Joint Venture, exported its first batch of 350 barrels of oil extracted from a field in Tamsag, Dornod to China.

    ¨ The Government’s “Green Revolution” kicks off, with the intention to dramatically increase the quantity of fruits and vegetables grown in Mongolia and to reduce dependence on foreign imports.

    ¨ The Youth–21 Ecoforum on Sustainable Development was organized by MAP-21, the Mongolian Youth Association and other NGOs.

    ¨ The Erdenet copper mine board decides to extend director general, Sh.Otgonbileg’s term by three months until May 25.

    ¨ An agreement between the Mongolian and South Korean governments allows 500 Mongolians to work in Korea for a two-year stint.

    ¨ The Buyant-Ukhaa airport in Ulaanbaatar, thanks to the Asian Development Bank, now has two fire trucks where it had none before.

    ¨ Canada opened its first diplomatic mission in Mongolia and plans are under way to open a Mongolian consulate in Canada’s financial capital, Toronto. The Canada Fund is spending US $100,000 on projects in Mongolia and 10 Canadian mining companies are employing 500 Mongolians.

    ¨ Workers at Mongolia’s largest industrial enterprise – Erdenet copper mine – walk off the job on February 23. The dispute erupted over rival candidates for membership of the board controlling the Mongolian-Russian joint venture. Erdenet accounts for one fourth of Mongolia’s state budget and 50 per cent of its exports.

    March 1998

    ¨ President N.Bagabandi makes an official visit to Kazakhstan, Kuwait and Turkey with an entourage of 20 people, including high-ranking officials and businessmen.

    ¨ Mongolian United Movement members, with their head G.Boshigt, started a sit-in at Sukhbaatar Square, blaming the Parliament and government for betraying promises made to the people.

    ¨ Three infants die and dozens of others are seriously ill due to the spread of sepsis at Maternity Ward No.1. An estimated 40 babies are being treated for the disease.

    ¨ It is announced by the National TB Centre that Mongolia has one of the world’s highest rates of tuberculosis infection. In 1995 Mongolia had 124.9 TB infections per 100,000 people – the fifth highest level in the world. To date 98.2 per cent of the country’s 3,600 TB patients are receiving treatment in hospital.

    April 1998

    ¨ The government formed by Prime Minister M.Enkhsaihan resigns. Ts. Elbegdorj, the leader of the Democratic Union Coalition (Mongolian National Democratic Party and the Mongolian Social Democratic Party) and Parliamentary deputy speaker, takes over as Prime Minister of Mongolia.

    ¨ A Federation of Mongolian Trade Unions demonstration called for better wages, benefits, vacations and an improved social welfare policy. The demonstration arose from the Parliament’s decision to postpone allowances and benefits issued from the social insurance and social welfare fund. The on-going demonstrations by the Mongolian United Movement, led by G. Boshigt, remained defiant. They demanded a response from the President, Parliament and the Government to their 23-point petition.

    ¨ Severe storms in the western aimags killed two people, 43,500 animals, destroyed 1,200 dwellings and buildings and several electronic stakes. Total damages were estimated at Tg 1.4 billion.

    ¨ Over 100 guns capable of firing rubber bullets were distributed to environmental control officers across Mongolia. Poaching and illegal logging are on the rise, as well as assaults on park staff.

    ¨ The number of Mongolians donating blood declined dramatically in the first quarter of 1998. Officials pin the plunge down to increased fears of HIV infection in the wake of several highly publicized cases.

    ¨ Health organizations won the right to make money after members of the State Ikh Hural social policy standing committee voted against adding the words “non-profit” to the definition of health organizations in the proposed health law.

    May 1998

    ¨ US Secretary of State, Madeleine Albright paid a seven-hour visit to Mongolia on May 2 and praised the country as being “independent and peaceful, proud and free.” She noted that trade doubled with the US in 1997 – but at US $50.9 million it still lagged behind Russia, China and Switzerland.

    ¨ President N.Bagabandi made an official visit to Japan from May 13-18 through the invitation of the Japanese government.

    ¨ Newly-appointed Minister of Finance, B.Batbayar, adopts resolution 80 on May 27, merging the bankrupt state-owned Reconstruction Bank with the private Golomt Bank.

    ¨ In the same week that MIAT, the national airline, celebrated its 73rd anniversary with the introduction of an Airbus 300 to its fleet, a Chinese-built Yu-12 plane crashed killing all aboard. Twenty-eight crew and passengers perished, including 16 adults, seven children and five teenagers. The Yu-12 has a poor safety record in Mongolia but no cause has yet been determined for the crash. An investigation continues.

    ¨ Spring fires continued to burn across many parts of Mongolia, though officials say most of the blazes were extinguished. So far in 1998, 91 steppe and forest fires have been reported in 12 aimags.

    ¨ Mongol TV began night broadcasts on May 2, extending its evening broadcasting schedule until 1 a.m. The late-night lineup begins with the 11 o’clock news and features sports and entertainment programming between midnight and 1 a.m, including a popular Disco TV show.

    ¨ Mongol Telecom (MONTEL) reported profits of Tg 3.6 billion in 1997, two-and-a-half times the previous year’s level. The state-run company is 40 per cent owned by Korea Telecom.

    ¨ The government allocated Tg 410 million (US $512,000) from the central budget to repair the damage caused by wind and dust storms in the western aimags. Total damages were estimated at Tg 1.4 billion (US $1.7 million). The spring storms in which winds reached 162 kilometres per hour, claimed the lives of two people and 43,500 livestock and levelled 1,200 gers.

    ¨ Anti-government protestors blocked downtown roads in Ulaanbaatar on May 19. The protest was organized by the Mongolian United Movement and consisted mainly of pensioners demanding the resignation of the government. MUM is facing a lawsuit by the city for obstructing traffic.

    June 1998

    ¨ MIAT general director, Ch. Alexander, stepped down on June 5 along with G. Ganbaatar of the Civil Aviation Authority, in the wake of the May plane crash. Alexander was replaced by former Infrastructure Minister, G. Nyamdavaa.

    ¨ An International Investors Forum on Agro-Industry and Tourism took place during June 24-26, involving over 200 foreign and 500 domestic representatives.

    ¨ Parliament was paralyzed by a two-day debate and a subsequent walk-out by the opposition over charges that resolution 80 on the bank merger was illegal.

    ¨ Over 13 000 firearms were legally imported into Mongolia between 1995 and June 1998, pushing up the total of firearms to 45 000.

    July 1998

    ¨ MPRP candidate, D.Tseveenjav, wins a by-election with 70.8 per cent of the vote. It is the third by-election in a row the MPRP has won since the general election two years ago.

    ¨ The newly appointed Government resigned on July 25 after a secret poll; 42 members or 56 per cent voted for the government resignation and 33 against.

    ¨ As part of a scheme to fight desertification in the Gobi desert border town of Zamyn-Uud, the Ministry of Environment plans to spend Tg 80 million (US $100,000) to transport sand dunes five kilometres outside the city.

    ¨ Long-awaited new ID cards for Mongolians were delayed until the government transferred funds to the British company making the cards. The new ID cards are to replace passports and will re-introduce Mongol family names in addition to given and paternal names.

    ¨ A US $30 million World Bank project will tackle electricity waste in the capital. According to the head of the power authority, Mr. Erdenbileg, 13 -14 per cent is squandered because of poor technology and another 30 per cent is pilfered by consumers.

    ¨ Heavy rains and flooding across the country claimed 12 lives and provided a stark contrast to the drought-like conditions that started the summer.

    August 1998

    ¨ President Bagabandi intervenes in a two-week-long hunger strike by the Mongolian United Youth Movement, calling for it to end and the protestors to use legal channels. Under an agreement with acting Prime Minister, Ts. Elbegdorj, the protest stopped with a pledge from the government to pay more attention to social policy.

    ¨ A private members’ bill in the Parliament calls for a 15 per cent tariff on all imported foodstuffs between September 1 and April 1. The bill hopes to protect the domestic food industry.

    ¨ An amendment to the education law makes it compulsory for Mongolian children to start school at age six. Mongolians currently begin first grade at age eight, one of the highest school-starting ages in the world.

    ¨ The power authority announces it will cut electricity supplies to recalcitrant debtors starting August 15. The Authority said it had no choice, stating repairs and winter preparations had stopped and that a debt of US $14 million was still outstanding. 70 per cent of power users in Darkhan, Baganuur, Erdenet and the ger istricts of Ulaanbaatar experienced cut-offs.

    ¨ A disabled man sets himself alight on August 13 during a demonstration in Freedom Square. Ts. Jambal doused himself in petrol and ignited it. He suffered burns to his legs and said he could not survive on Tg 6,420 a month while supporting a wife and three children.

    September 1998

    ¨ The media landscape is set for a major shake-up with the passing of the long-awaited media law on August 28. The state-owned newspapers Zasgyn Gazrin Medee and Ardyn Erkh – Mongolia’s most widely read paper – are to be abolished under the law. The law, designed to promote democracy and pluralism in society, bans state ownership and state control of the media. Newspapers and radio stations supported by local governors will also be affected as well as the giant national broadcaster Mongol TV and Radio. The law will take effect on January 1, 1999.

    ¨ Mongolian Traditional United Party MP, O. Dashbalbar, has suggested that debt evaders be strung from a pole. “Let’s execute them if necessary,” he said to Parliament.

    ¨ The national oil-import company, NIC hiked prices by 12.5 per cent starting September 2.

    ¨ Over 30 agencies, studios and publishers have joined the newly formed Mongolian Advertising Association. The advocacy group chose Foreign Investment Board chief, D. Jargalsaikhan, as its first president.

    ¨ Mongolia will have an open market with regards to both Internet providers and cellular phones as of January 1, 1999. The Mobicom cell phone company will lose its monopoly status, as well as, the Datacom Internet provider.

    October 1998

    ¨ Sanjaasuren Zorig, the democracy campaigner turned politician, was murdered upon his return to his apartment on October 2.

    Political Changes

    By the middle of January the Parliament approved elected MPs being members of the Cabinet; a move that was to have profound significance for the Enksaikhan government in the months to come. The Mongolian 1992 constitution prohibited members of the State Ikh Hural from taking on other state duties. An amendment to the law on MPs’ legal status adopted earlier by this Parliament interprets the edict to mean that – unlike in most parliamentary democracies – MPs cannot serve in the Cabinet.

    In February the leaders of the governing coalition partners – the National Democratic Party and the Mongolian Social Democratic Party – appealed for a merger. Opinion varied widely on the reason for the proposed merger, with some seeing it as a sign of political crisis while others see it more like a natural evolution for two parties with similar ideologies. The Social Democrats were also being wooed by the opposition Mongolian People’s Revolutionary Party to form powerful centre-left bloc. Rumours were also starting about a Russian-style overhaul of the Cabinet.

    In a bizarre move on March 27, the general council of the Mongolian National Democratic Party voted for the resignation of its government. The suggestion came from party president and Deputy Speaker, Ts. Elbegdorj, soon to supercede Prime Minister, Enkhsaikhan. At the time, Elbegdorj suggested that the Coalition government’s current low public approval came down to a lack of coordination between the government and the State Ikh Hural. “The government has not acted in line with the wishes of the Parliament and should resign,” he said at the time. Parliament resumed on April 6 after a two-and-half month break during which fissures in the Coalition appeared. Prime Minister, Enkhsaikhan, complained that a faction in the party was trying to oust him. He was right. On April 17, a day after an extraordinary joint meeting of the ruling councils of the MNDP and MSDP, Prime Minister, Enkhsaikhan, handed his resignation to President, N. Bagabandi. It was approved by the State Ikh Hural on April 22 by a vote of 591. Ten MPs boycotted the session, saying the move was unconstitutional.

    The resignation provoked mixed reactions amongst Mongolians. Some felt it would speed up the pace of reform. Others saw it as a grab for power by a faction in the Coalition, or worried about the lack of experience of a Cabinet of MPs.

    Youngest PM

    The new Prime Minister, Ts. Elbegdorj, took office on April 23, vowing to chart the same economic course as his predecessor, and to operate a more open and transparent government. Although he replaced a number of senior civil servants, he said he would not make changes to the structure of the nine government Ministries.

    He vowed to press forward with a busy spring session, in which a number of bills central to the government’s programme — including a new law on foreign investment and a long-awaited media law — were slated to be passed.

    But he immediately ran into trouble. Elbegdorj nominated his nine-member Cabinet April 27, but only five of the nominees received the approval of Parliament. The process came to border on farce, as nominee after nominee was shot down in the State Ikh Hural. The last Minister — Education Minister Ch. Saikhanbileg — was not approved until May 28. He was the fifth nominee put forward for the post. The local media expressed concern about the average age of 35.8. In place at last, some people began to worry about its lack of experience.

    Then, at the beginning of June, the 25 Opposition MPs began a boycott in protest over the government-approved merger of the 18-month-old state-owned Sergeen Bosgoltyn (Reconstruction) Bank with the private Golomt Bank. The merger, which the government carried out with the backing of international financial institutions, was necessary, said the Finance Minister. The Reconstruction Bank was insolvent, with 70 per cent of its Tg 11.2 billion (U.S. $13.7 million) in outstanding loans classed as unreliable.

    The Opposition labelled the merger a “conspiracy”, charging the government with driving the bank to its doom by racking up Tg 8.7 billion ($10.5 million) in debts and pointing to links between the Golomt Bank and members of the National Democratic Party.

    The result was a Parliament paralysed for all of June. Key bills — including the foreign investment bill slated to be approved before a June 24-26 investors’ conference in Ulaanbaatar — languished.

    Government Minister Murdered

    The crisis deepened when a large majority of an all-party task force appointed to investigate the merger, ruled that the move was improper. The President warned that if the impasse was not resolved soon, he would have no choice but to dissolve the State Ikh Hural and call an early election.

    “Even if the government resigns or there is a new election, it will not mean that Mongolia will reverse its chosen path,” Prime Minister, Elbegdorj, told journalists on June 18. “The people have already made their choice.”

    On July 25 Prime Minister, Ts. Elbegdorj, and his entire cabinet resigned after a secret poll, with 56 per cent of MPs voting for the Government’s resignation. On October 2, one of the founders of the democratic movement and acting minister for infrastructure development, S. Zorig, was murdered on returning to his apartment. At the time of writing the Parliament was still searching for a replacement Prime Minister to form a new governmen, and Zorig was hinted at being a contender.

    The opposition MPRP further distanced itself from the past by adopting in May a new logo. Replacing the traditional communist red star with a red rose – the international emblem of social democracy – and a yin-yang symbol, expressing the creative and receptive forces of nature. The party also passed a resolution expressing “deep regret” for the “tragic” purges of the 1930s and 0s, in which as many as 30,000 Mongolians died.

    Major Legislation

    The autumn session of the Parliament came to a close on January 23, 1998. It was a busy session with 91 laws adopted out of a total 172 draft laws and 60 resolutions. Thirty new laws were adopted, 52 were amendments to existing laws, and eight invalidated old laws. They included issues relating to social problems, reforms to social policy, a law on the five-day work week and legislation defining the minimum subsistence level and the minimum wage.

    The 1998 spring session started on April 5 and planned to adopt 43 draft laws. By July 1, nine laws were drafted, four were amended and one invalidated an old law. The legislative agenda was slowed down by the change in prime ministers, and the on-going political crisis surrounding controversies like the much-criticized Golomt and Reconstruction Bank merger.

    The priorities for 1998 include health care, medications, hygiene and sanitation, science and technology, national security and mobilization. According to the plan, the following draft laws will be debated: state budget, administration and financing of state organizations, mass media and freedom of information, elections and lobbying.

    In late January, the Prevention of Crime law went into effect. It prohibits the media from publishing details of crimes and criminal trials. Supporters of the law say the plethora of newspapers and TV programmes reporting on crime are actually encouraging it. Critics of the law claimed it was a step backwards to state censorship and that out of sight does not necessarily mean out of mind.

    In September, the Media Law was passed. It removes the state from any involvement in the media as of January 1, 1999. This affects newspapers and the leviathan state broadcaster, Mongol TV and Radio

    The Economy – Inflation

    Macro economic indicators showed some very encouraging results in 1997. The State Statistics Office showed inflation dropping from over 300 per cent only several years ago, to 17.5 per cent for the year. According to former Minister of Finance, P.Tsagaan, ‘The liberalization of prices, the abolition of import taxes, a deep restructuring process in the banking and financial sector, changes to the tax system and a strict credit policy conditioned the decrease of inflation down to 17.5 per cent per annum. The GDP increased by 3.3 per cent per annum.’ Others attributed the lowering inflation rate to the reduced purchasing power of the population.

    By July 1998, inflation had dropped below ten per cent for the first time since Mongolia’s transition to a market economy, according to the SSO. This was attributed to a tough monetary policy and limits on credits to banks and the government.

    The consumer price index (CPI) increased for housing, fuel and electricity by 50.7 per cent, clean water per capita by two-fold, goods and services and education by 41.4 per cent, clothes, shoes and cotton materials by 30.5 per cent and medicine, vaccines and medical services by 26.6 per cent.

    9.2 per cent; for 1997 it was 28.9 per cent. In March of 1998, due to meat price increases of between 30 and 40 per cent, the CPI grew by 4.2 per cent compared with February 1998.

    In accordance with the September 1997 report of the State Statistical Office, the average household monetary income for urban areas was Tg 63,900, and in rural areas Tg 48,400. The average household monetary expenditures reached Tg 62,500 in urban areas, and Tg 48,500 in rural areas.

    Exchange Rate

    The national currency, the tugrug, stabilized its exchange rate with foreign currencies in 1998. During the last eight months of 1997, the average monthly fluctuation in the exchange rate ranged within 0.37 per cent.

    Market exchange rate by October 1998: US $1=Tg 855

    The Bank of Mongolia posted in June 1998 the following rates for buying foreign currencies: DM 463.59; JPY 5.90; CHF 549.96; GBP 1393.38 and HKD 108.28.

    Monetary and Banking Developments

    The Bank of Mongolia maintained a tight monetary policy in 1997, aimed at reducing inflation and stabilizing the currency. This tight monetary policy continued in 1998. the hallmark of this policy is the policy of monetary management through reserve money. The coordination of monetary policy instruments has been based on factors affecting the economy, including demand and supply. As a result of these activities, the inflation rate declined three times in 1997 from 1996. This price stability has been a significant achievement, which established a strong foundation for economic growth and an increase in real income.

    The Bank of Mongolia reported at the end of May 1998 that the total money supply had reached Tg 166.4 billion, when at the end of the previous year it was Tg 170.06 billion. Individual deposits reached Tg 54.9 billion by the end of 1997, and Tg 52.3 billion by June 1998. Interest rates for medium term domestic currency deposits are fixed between 12 and 42.6 per cent in 1998, and 1.2 and 26.8 per cent for foreign currency deposits. In the previous year it was 6 to 69.6 per cent and 3.7 to 42.6 per cent repectively.

    The solvency of the national commercial banks increased two-fold in 1997. The net international reserve reached in 1997 US $107.15 million – a figure twice that of 1996. This was due to gold reserves surpassing 8,000 kg of pure gold, 48.4 per cent more than 1996. As of June 1998, the net international reserve is US $69.17 million. Outstanding loans stood at Tg 50.3 billion at the end of 1997, marking a 22.2 per cent decrease against 1996. It was Tg 74 billion as of June 1998.

    The Debt Collection Service collected Tg 5.4 billion in 1997, and plans to bring back another Tg 5 billion this year.

    In conformity with its 1998 work plan, the Bank of Mongolia desires to keep inflation no higher than 20 per cent; increases in money supply no lower than 25 per cent; and net foreign currency reserves to reach US $80 million.

    In the framework of the government’s monetary policy, the following will be done this year: bank restructuring, increasing bank solvency and current capital, restoring inter-bank mutual trust and monetary market operation, defending consumer rights, maintaining competition as well as implementing bank privatization.

    A Value Added Tax was introduced as of July 1, and then raised from 10 to 13 per cent. The new tax is to meet International Monetary Fund conditions. The Consumers’ Rights Association said costs are rising because of the VAT. They pointed to the 30 per cent hike in domestic airfares, petrol hikes and a 20 per cent increase for milk products.

    Foreign Aid and Investment

    The October 1997 Tokyo International Donor Meeting saw pledges of US $250 million in loans and grants being made – an amount equal to the state budget revenue of Mongolia. Most of the donors contribute to infrastructure development, namely highways and transportation, power stations and communication.

    Since 1991, loans to the Mongolian Government reached US $560 million, most being long-term, low interest loans. In 1997, foreign grants reached Tg 6.3 billion.

    It was revealed by the government that only five per cent of foreign aid is spent on the social sector. Of US $180 million in aid slated for 1998, 30 per cent will go to mining, 27 per cent to energy, 19 per cent to transport, eight per cent to communications, five per cent to social security and three per cent to other areas.

    Japan continued to hold its status as Mongolia’s largest bilateral donor. A record US $20 million was pledged for 1998. USAID is spending US $2.2 million on diesel power generators to non-grid power stations in five aimags.

    The German Reconstruction Bank extended to Mongolia a soft loan of DM 15 million to overhaul the power station in Choibalson, Dornod aimag. In June the Foreign Credit and Aid Coordinating Unit was replaced by the Foreign Investment, Credit and Aid Coordinating Unit based at the Foreign Relations Ministry.

    Under an Asian Development Bank project, the French firm Alcatel is replacing 150 kilometres of telephone cable in Ulaanbaatar, Darhan and Erdenet. It says 50,000 new customers will be hooked up to the phone system as a result of the US $21 million scheme.

    Mongolia spent US $108.9 million in loans and grants from donors in 1998 as of November, of more than US $205 million committed. The Government established the Foreign Investment and Loan Coordination Council in an attempt to streamline the use of incoming foreign funds.

    Fiscal Situation

    Total state budget revenues for 1997 were Tg 207.5 billion (excluding grants), of which 5.1 per cent was the current revenue; 83.8 per cent or Tg 165.5 billion and 16.2 per cent or Tg 31.8 billion were tax and non-tax revenue repectively. The total budget expenditures reached Tg 298.5 billion (excluding net lending), of which 65.9 per cent were current expenditures, and 34.1 per cent were capital expenditure. The total budget deficit stood at Tg 90.9 billion. The State Property Committee contributed Tg 13.4 billion to the state budget, and grants Tg 6.1 billion.

    For 1998, state budget revenues are projected to reach Tg 214.9 billion and expenditures Tg 293.9 billion, with the deficit standing at Tg 79 billion. Budget revenues are to be derived from tax income of Tg 143.8 billion, non-tax income of Tg 45.9 billion, privatization income of Tg 16 billion, and foreign loans and grants of Tg 9.1 billion.

    According to state budget projections for 1998, the highest subsidy to a local budget will be given to Gobi-Altai, at Tg 2.3 billion, and the lowest is Gobi-Sumber , with Tg 609 million.

    As of June 1998, total revenuse and grants reached Tg 102.3 billion for the general government budget, of which Tg 77.3 billion went to the central governmental, and Tg 26.8 billion to local government budgets.

    Foreign-currency reserves shrunk by a quarter since the beginning of 1998. Mongol Bank figures set the reserves at the end of the first half of 1998 at US $75.7 million, $15.7 million more than a year ago. But the fund is down from a high of US $100 million at the beginning of the year. Due to drops in world prices for cashmere and copper, the government has been forced to sell off large chunks of foreign currency to keep the tugrug stable.

    Industrial and Real Sector Developments

    Despite modest gains in 1996/97, industrial productivity in 1998 was 46.1 per cent lower than in 1989, according to the Ministry of Agriculture and Industry. Coal production was down 38.5 per cent, cement 40.4 per cent, glass and chinaware 96.6 per cent, building materials 53 per cent, leather goods 97 per cent and sheepskin goods 98 per cent.

    Construction Sector

    In 1997, 820 housing apartments worth Tg 7.2 billion were built. Construction and capital repair worth Tg 44.4 billion was done by domestic and foreign companies, a Tg 5 billion increase in money being spent, but a five per cent decrease in construction work being completed against 1996.

    As of June 1998, construction and capital repair worth Tg 17.2 billion was done. Total construction work performance is impeded by poor investment in upgrading skills and equipment.

    Gross Industrial Production

    The State Statistical Office reported that in 1997 the industrial sector employed 62,000 persons, with gross industrial output reaching Tg 454.7 billion – a growth of 4.4 per cent or Tg 9 billion against 1996. GDP increased by 3.3 per cent against 1996.

    Total output broke down as follows: 58 per cent produced by mining of metal ores, quarrying stone, coal and other mining sector; 17.3 per cent by electricity, thermal energy generation; 13 per cent by manufacturing of food products and beverages; and the remaining parts by other sectors. Production in coal mining, textile sector, clothing, wood, skin and hide processing declined in 1997.

    As of June 1998, gross industrial output reached Tg 210.8 billion or 33 per cent of output reached by June 1997.

    Mining

    Mongolian mines delivered 8,902 kilograms of gold to the central bank in 1997 – 2,905 kg more than in 1996.

    In May, the Sharyn Gol coal mine – 240 kilometres north of Ulaanbaatar – stopped production for eight days because it could not afford to buy supplies, carry out repairs or pay its workers. Sharyn Gol, which produces a million tonnes of coal a year, is the major supplier to the mammoth Erdenet mining enterprise, power stations in Darkhan and Erdenet cities and Ulaanbaatar’s Power Station #3. The mine is owed more than Tg 6 billion (US $7.5 million) by its customers.

    In July, Australia’s BHT company claimed it had discovered a copper deposit in Dungov aimag larger than the deposit at the Erdenet mine.

    Service Sector Development

    Though statistics are difficult to find, there has been a substantial increase in the service sector, most of it in the capital, Ulaanbaatar.. 1998 will be remembered as the year of renovations and conversions. Many ground floor apartments and older buildings were spruced up to take on a new life as a shop, restaurant or bar. The range and quality of goods available has also substantially increased. The capital now boasts restaurants selling French, Italian, Indian, Senagalese and American cuisine. Macroeconomic insentives to start businesses are now beginning to pay off. The capital has taken a different hue, buzzing with activity. Outside the capital this service sector revolution hasn’t taken off. Mongolians are saying “Everything is available for those who can afford it.”

    Foreign Trade Developments

    According to a 1997 report by the SSO, total external turnover equaled US $1.026 billion, of which exports were worth US $ 451.5 million and imports US $574.7 million. The trade deficit stood at US $123.2 million, a US $96.6 million or 14.7 per cent increase against 1996. Imports increased by 21 per cent or US $ 123.8 billion.

    The decrease of exports was caused by an overall fall in export products, with copper concentrate dropping by 2.7 per cent, flourite spar concentrate by 3.6 per cent, goat processed cashmere by 15.2 per cent and non-processed cashmere by 8.3 per cent.

    As of June 1998, total turnover equaled US $371.6 million, including exports of US $140.9 million, and imports of US $230.7 million. The deficit stood at US $89.8 million. Main export markets were Switzerland, China, the Russian Federation, South Korea, USA, Great Britain, Japan, Italy and Germany. In the first five months of 1998, the SSO found that while imports continued to increase, the prices for basic goods were also rising. From January 1 to June 1 of 1998, Mongolia racked up US $186.2 million in exports, against US $114.3 million in imports. That’s US $40.3 million less in exports and US $59.9 million more in imports than in the same period last year. Prices for basic consumer goods rose by 12.2 per cent between December 1997 and June 1998. The production of 88 made-in-Mongolia products increased over 1997. Production of 58 items declined and 10 items previously produced in the country – including matches and batteries – are now to be imported.

    The number of foreign joint ventures and wholly owned companies registered in Mongolia now stands at 820.

    The head of the Ulaanbaatar Trade Union, Mr. D. Jadambaa, charged in May that too many foreign joint-venture businesses were exploiting Mongolian workers. The Union made an audit of 27 joint-venture companies for compliance with Mongolia’s labour laws and safety and sanitation regulations. They claimed to have found 25 infractions of the rules and fined one business Tg 40,000. Jadambaa, however, praised foreign investment and said the government should work together with unions to make sure standards are upheld.

    Agriculture

    Livestock

    The State Statistical Office reported that, out of 31.3 million heads of livestock registered in 1997, there were 14.1 million sheep, 10.2 million goats, 3.6 million cows, 2.9 million horses and 355,400 camels.

    Since 1990 livestock increased by 20.9 per cent or 5.4 million heads, in which 5.1 million or 94.9 per cent of the growth is attributed to goats. This is due to increasing interest among herders in producing cashmere for export, despite falling prices.

    Statistics for June 1998 show that 80 per cent of 10.4 million breeding stock gave birth, and 9.7 million heads of new-borns survived. Natural losses of adult animals as of June 1998 totalled 2 per cent of total livestock or 6.1 million. The figure for 1997 was 1.5 per cent or 4.5 million.

    In July the British ATL company signed a US $2 million meat-processing agreement with Mongolia’s Nomgon Bar company, to process and market Mongolia’s pure, eco-friendly meat using a system of vacuum sealing and refrigerated transportation.

    Crops

    Green Revolution

    The Ministry of Agriculture blamed financial and technical problems for delaying the crop harvest in 1998. Only half of the country’s grain- and potatoe-harvesting exquipment has undergone repairs this year. Problems with the Golomt and Reconstruction banks has meant farmers are unable to get loans for much-needed fuel and parts.

    In 1998, the total area sown reached 323,150.9 hectares – 98.3 per cent of 1997’s area. Potatoes and vegetables sown this year increased by 122.3 per cent and 146.5 per cent respectively against 1997.

    The government’s Green Reovolution is said to have involved 70,000 families and 920 businesses planting 10,000 hectares of fruits and vegetables.

    Due to a shortage of domestic flour production, 11,000 tonnes of wheat were donated by the US Government to Mongolia at the end of 1997.

    Mongolia spends US $40 million a year to import vegetables.

    In August 1998 the US government announced it was going to donate 24 tonnes of wheat valued at US $5 million to Mongolia. Mongolia will ship US $6 million worth of meat and fluorspar to Russia in 1998, as payment for outstanding debts to its northern neighbour.

    Privatization

    The State Property Committee called 1997 a huge success in Mongolia’s ongoing efforts to privatize business. Some 212 economic entities, including 97 state companies, were sold during the first phase of a three-year privatization programme, contributing Tg 13.4 billion to the state budget. These included 20,267 apartments. Sales of small- and medium-sized business was most effective.

    The Committee sold 14 crop-farming enterprises at an open bid in 1997. Privatization of the remaining 40 enterprises on the list is planned for this year.

    The Property Privatization Board transferred Tg 6.7 billion to the central government budget, and Tg 444.3 million to the local government budget as of June 30, 1998. Thirty-seven auctions were organized in Ulaanbaatar, in which six properties, 29 economic entities, three limited companies were sold. One third, or 25,000 apartments out of a total 75,000, were privatized.

    Local privatizations brought in by June 1998 Tg 787.9 million to the state budget.

    In the area of land privatization, the government has promised it only affect 0.6 per cent of the country. Pasture land, Special Protected Areas and land regarded as public property would be exempt from privatization.

    By May 1998 the Government admitted privatization was going slowly. As of that date, only 390 of 1,114 entities slated for privatization since 1996 have been sold off. Privatization of the largest businesses began in March 1998, but most of the larger entities – including the state airline MIAT and Gobi Cashmere – remain in government hands. High price tags and operating costs deter would-be buyers. Both the high-rise Ardyn Bank building and the State Department Store have failed to shift despite repeated attempts at auction.

    By September 1998, 50,000 families became homeowners since housing privatization was introduced in 1997.

    Social Issues

    Unemployment

    Official statistics registered 63,600 unemployed people at the labor exchange at the end of 1997, and 55,800 as of June 1998. The unemployment rate totaled 7.6 per cent at the end of 1997, with 25.5 per cent or the highest unemployment in Dornod aimag.

    The number of unemployed entering the workforce is 10,800 as of June 1998. The number of unemployed newly registered in the first six months of 1998 decreased by 12,003 from 21,673 in 1997. The Ministry of Health’s Labour Coordinating Office estmated that more than 200,000 people – 20 per cent of the working-age population – do not have formal jobs. The number of Mongolians officially registered as unemployed as of June stands at 62,200. Nearly two-thirds of the officially unemployed have no professional training.

    Women account for 48 per cent of Mongolian workers, or 363,831 of the country’s 756,043 working people. But they make up 51 per cent of the registered unemployed, or 31,208 of 61, 504.

    Poverty

    Official statistics at the end of 1997 showed the number of poor in the country had reached 587,741, comprising 149,647 households. The poverty level is 24.6 per cent of the population. 142,300 poor or 26,189 households live in Ulaanbaatar, while 56,328 poor – the highest number outside of Ulaanbaatar -live in Huvsgul aimag. 40.6 per cent of the poor are neither employed nor in school; 23.6 per cent are single-mother parents. The number of single-mother households in the country reached 51,700, showing a 12.4 per cent increase against 1996. Out of the poor population, 46.6 per cent are children under 16, 45.8 per cent are working age, and 7.6 per cent are elderly.

    The minimum subsistence level (MSL) has not been revised since February 1997.

    The number of Mongolians leaving the countryside for Ulaanbaatar in search of economic opportunities is increasing. In the first half of 1998, 6,518 people – most of them between the ages of 18 and 39 – resettled in the capital. That’s 60 per cent more than in the same period last year. Faced with overloaded social services and rising unemployment, the Ulaanbaatar government is keen to curb this mushrooming of the city’s population. Official figures say the capital is home to 640,000 people, but unofficial estimates go as high as 1 million. It costs Tg 26,000 (US $32) to register as an Ulaanbaatar citizen and receive social benefits.

    The United Nations Development Programme has been a supporter of Mongolia’s development efforts since the 1970s. A new five-year programme (1997 to 2001) called the Partnership for Progress, is into its second year. These UNDP activities support the Mongolian Government’s Programme of Action (November, 1996), with its priority on economic growth under difficult transition conditions.

    This year has seen a number of landmark activities. The United Nations as a system has signed with the Mongolian Government a Memorandum of Understanding on youth issues. Two more MOUs are due to be signed on Food Security and Nutrition and Human Rights. At UNDP, the priority has been to assist the Mongolian Government in the development of a relevant social policy to meet the challenges of free markets and democracy. This has entailed close consultation with the government, most particularly in the frequent visits of a Japanese specialist on human development. Work is under way on the 1999 Mongolian Human Development Report (the first was published in 1997). The Government has chosen the theme “Human Development and Government Services” for this report.

    Human Development

    Microcredit experience in Mongolia

    UNDP is spending US $1 million to kick off the microfinance experience in Mongolia for the first time. The project, signed in June 1997, is underway with the executing agency ACDI/VOCA, a US microfinance consulting firm.

    Main outputs of the project include a national microfinance institution (MFI) providing technical service to other MFIs and loans; at least five local professional MFIs; 7,500 loans being disbursed; and a target of 50 percent women beneficiaries by the end of the project.

    Support to formulation of social policy in Mongolia

    Last year the Mongolian Government took decisive steps in the reform process in governance and macroeconomy. UNDP Mongolia is working to assist the government in identifying viable social policy options to balance these economic reforms. A preparatory report has been prepared by Professor Ryokichi Hirono, a well-known Japanese economist. UNDP Mongolia is leading an effort with the Government, UNICEF and Save the Children Fund (UK) to identify options for the development of a new national social policy framework. The policy options uphold sustainable human development paradigms and are consistent with the nation’s ongoing political and economic reforms. The inputs from UNDP and UNICEF on this review of social policy options support national and international consultants, various workshops and training.

    The review exercise will be conducted in two phases, incorporating social policy options and a national social policy framework. It is foreseen that the recommendations will be finalized in September 1998.

    The issue was also broadly discussed at the 5th forum of the Economic Club (under UNDP’s Economic and Social Growth Think Tank Project).

    Helping to renovate the wheat seed pool in Mongolia for sustainable food security

    UNDP’s Emergency Production of High Quality Wheat Seed and New Variety Testing Project has allocated US $100,000 for the purchase of high quality wheat seed from Kazakhstan. The present wheat seed pool in Mongolia is at six to seven generations, consequently, the productive quality is low. For the purpose of rejuvenating the seed pool, about 200 tonnes of high quality wheat seed were imported. The seed was distributed to 11 private sector cereal farms for multiplication purposes under the supervision of a local consultancy company. In autumn, 400 tonnes of the high quality seed will be put into the seed revolving fund. This is a critical initiative to boost food security in line with the priorities and market reforms of Mongolia.

    Support to Mongolia’s 1998 Green Revolution

    With the help of UNDP’s funds, 10,000 households in Ulaanbaatar City were provided with instruction booklets on how to grow fruits and vegetables. In connection with the national Green Revolution programme of the Mongolian Government, UNDP is spending US $20,000 from its seed project to help purchase vegetable and fruit seeds and seedlings. In order to ensure the successful delivery of the support, the Poverty Alleviation Study Centre, an emerging national NGO, has been contracted for the job.

    Support to formulation of water and sanitation policy in Mongolia

    Under UNDP’s WASH-21 project (National Water Sanitation and Hygiene Education for the 21st Century), a study to tour to India took place in the framework of water and sanitation policy review and formulation. The tour focused on water and sanitation policy and management issues, with cost-sharing by UNDP and SIDA. As well, a full-scale policy formulation workshop will take place at the beginning of July, and the first draft of the policy will be presented to the Government of Mongolia in September 1998.

    Environment and Natural Resource Management

    MAP-21 for the 21st century is adopted

    As the follow-up to Mongolia’s commitment to the Rio de Janeiro Agenda-21, the Mongolian Action Programme for the 21st century (MAP-21) was launched at a national summit. The National Sustainable Development Action Programme incorporates the Sustainable Development Action Programmes of the 21 provinces. During the Summit, the 40-page executive summary was launched in both English and Mongolian. The summary lays out the national development strategy and how the Government and civil society can work together. Mongolia’s Business Council for Sustainable Development was established to support among other things MAP-21. The Council will be promoting the benefits of sustainable development to the private sector.

    Support to biodiversity conservation

    The fragile steppe grasslands of Eastern Mongolia, considered a global treasure, will become a protected area under a new seven-year, UNDP project signed with the Government of Mongolia. The over US $6 million project, “Biodiversity Conservation and Sustainable Livelihood Options in the Grasslands of Eastern Mongolia“, is intended to prevent the unsustainable exploitation of the animals, plants and ecosystems of an area that is being targetted for oil exploration and mining. This innovative project will involve local people as environmental custodians, weaving the goals of environmental protection into sustainable livelihoods. Local governments in three provinces will receive support to incorporate biodiversity into local planning. Any profits from economic activities in the buffer zones will be plowed back into a Community Fund to be used by citizens. The Mongolian government hopes to increase the amount of territory under protection from 11.6 per cent to 15 per cent by the year 2000.

    UNDP is working in partnership with the US Peace Corps, three Mongolian ecotourism companies and the governments of Finland and the Netherlands.The signing of the project was part of celebration of the World Environment Day on 5 June 1998.

    UNDP documents biodiversity of Mongolia

    The first national report on biodiversity in Mongolia was published in June. The report gives a broad description of the socio-economic development trends, environmental status, climate, flora and fauna of Mongolia and details government action so far, including the current status of protection, use and restoration.

    Governance and Economic Transition

    Support to the private sector

    UNDP has signed with the Government of Mongolia a US $2.6 million project to smooth the transition to a market economy. The project will provide national and international technical assistance to 10 newly privatised companies. These companies will be selected based on detailed criteria related to economic, social and environmental concerns. The project is intended to create a more dynamic private sector in Mongolia by reforming the operations of firms, introducing modern management techniques, developing models and methodologies for future enterprise reform and training staff. Despite the rapid introduction of market reforms, many private enterprises suffer from inexperience with the market economy. The end result is that these inefficiencies continue to contribute to low production and high unemployment; two consequences of transition that the project hopes to remedy. Funds for the “Enterprise Restructuring” project are being generously provided on a cost-sharing basis from the Government of the Netherlands.

    Support to the national Information Technology seminar

    UNDP Mongolia together with Asia-Pacific Development Information Programme (APDIP), held its first Information and Technology (IT) Seminar on the Internet in Kuala Lumpur. Tailored to the needs of the Mongolian Government delegation, the seminar was part of the preparation activities to the National IT summit that will take place this summer. Ministerial and private sector representatives, who are part of a working group to advise the Government on assessment, policies and implementation of IT strategy, participated in the seminar.

    Greater access for Mongolians to the Internet

    The APDIP contributed US $12,000 to UNDP Mongolia to be spent on establishing the fifth Citizen’s Information Service Center (CISC) in Dundgovi aimag (province) and to support the UN Information Shop’s Internet connection for the public. CISCs offer access to the Internet and E-mail while also providing courses on computer software. UNDP has supported the use of the Internet to help give Mongolians access to their government’s laws and the large amount of information produced by the central government in the capital.

    Workshop highlights accomplishments in IT

    A homepage competition capped a two-day workshop in May on maximizing the opportunities of IT. UNDP’s Information, Communication and Technology for Sustainable Human Development Project has hooked up 20 government ministries to an Intranet and the Internet. There was also a homepage design workshop for more than 150 organizations. The number of Mongolian homepages has surpassed 70 and more come on-line every week.

    The first Mongolian economics magazine

    UNDP Mongolia’s Economic and Social Growth Think Tank Project has initiated the first magazine to focus on economic developments in the country. Named “Development Economics”, the quarterly magazine probes further into the challenges of a transition to a market economy.

    Support to the development of new journalism in Mongolia

    Under the Support to Democracy through Strengthening Journalism Project, training was provided for regional journalists on surviving in the market economy. The thirty plus workshops of the project aim to change the concept of journalism in Mongolia, switching from journalism controlled by the state to a free press in a proper democracy. To assist the Parliament’s debate over a new media law, UNDP sponsored an opinion survey of journalists and politicians.

    HIV/AIDS/STDs

    Public awareness activities

    The discovery of two new HIV-positive cases at the end of 1997 led to a national crisis driven by media hysteria. This increased the number of known Mongolians infected with HIV from one to two. In 1998, UNDP Mongolia’s HIV/AIDS/STD team has been busy working with NGOs wishing to be involved in prevention andwareness-raising activities. Students were encouraged to amalgamate and form a student’s AIDS Club, which was launched at local disco, Top Ten. The UN-funded Mongolian AIDS Bulletin was distributed and a game was played with patrons of the disco. Short dramatic scenes showing how HIV is transmitted was performed by troupe of actors. As well, the training needs of the homosexual community were ascertained.a

    AIDS Foundation established

    At the launch of the National AIDS Foundation several private sector companies and NGOs pledged money for the Foundation. A total of about US $4,500 was raised, through a combination of cash pledges and in-kind (condoms) donations from organizations such as the Mongolian Red Cross Society, the Olympics Committee, Mongolian Consulting Services, etc. The most impressive donation was made by Erdenet miners, who pledged a day’s salary.

    Support to raising public awareness on the prevention of HIV/AIDS/ STDs

    Eleven NGOs are being contracted to work closely with the segments of society who are vulnerable to HIV/AIDS and STD infection. The UNDP component of the UNAIDS programme is funding these small projects to carry out prevention education among target groups. The target groups include commercial sex workers and their customers, businessmen, students, street and homeless children, homosexuals, military officers and prisoners. The projects will be aiming mainly at educating the educators.

    Creative Commons License

    This work is licensed under a
    Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.

    ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5311-1052.

    © David South Consulting 2026

  • Mongolia Update | May 1998

    Mongolia Update | May 1998

    Editor and Writer: David South

    Researcher: G. Enkhtungalug

    Layout: U. Byambajargal

    Publisher: UNDP Mongolia Communications Office

    Published: May 1998

    Political special

    This is an unofficial publication of UNDP. Views presented in this document do not necessarily reflect those of UNDP. Mongolia Update is provided as service to those who are interested in the rapid changes taking place in today’s Mongolia.

    Contents

    A year of change

    Who is who in the Cabinet

    What’s on the Government’s plate?

    1. Background — a year of change

    Mongolia’s first elected non-communist government, the Democratic Union Coalition, came to office in June 1996 with a strong mandate and a promise of sweeping social and economic change. The coalition of the Mongolian National Democratic Party and the Mongolian Social Democratic Party ran on the basis of a U.S.-style election platform, the Contract with Voters, and gained 50 of the 76 seats in the State Ikh Hural (Parliament).

    The new government’s action programme was founded on fundamental economic reform, including privatisation of the major industrial enterprises and the state-owned banks, liberalisation of prices and the abolition of import tariffs.

    The government achieved some success, including increasing foreign-currency reserves to nearly U.S. $100 million and a flourishing of small-scale private enterprise in the capital city, Ulaanbaatar.

    By the autumn of 1997, the Coalition was hoping to embark on large-scale privatisation and accelerated economic reform. But the government of Prime Minister M. Enkhsaikhan began to face opposition as the high social cost of the economic reforms began to become apparent.

    Leading off the protests were students. At the start of the academic year in September, college and university students, led by the Mongolian Students’ Union, staged an escalating series of protests that culminated in a one-day student strike. Their demand was a reduction in tuition fees — which had doubled in some cases — and in dormitory rents, also up sharply.

    After meeting with student leaders, the government acceded to their demands, instructing university directors to cut fees and slash dorm rents. But with no commitment of extra money from the government, university administrators warned cuts would have to be made in other areas, including supplies and instructors’ salaries.

    From the opening day of the autumn session of the State Ikh Hural on October 1, the Opposition Mongolian People’s Revolutionary Party went on the attack. Opposition leader N. Enkhbayar, elected to Parliament in an August by-election, used his maiden speech to demand the resignation of the government. He accused the Coalition of ignoring its election promise to cut taxes by 20 to 30 per cent, of bungling privatisation and of neglecting the social sphere.

    The government, he said, “is serving the interests of a few companies — including those of some members of the State Ikh Hural — while overburdening the nation’s small- and medium-sized industries.”

    The MPRP demand was backed by demonstrations organised by the party, trade unions and activist groups like the Mongolian United Movement. But these protests were small and made up largely of pensioners, one of the groups hardest hit by shrinking social spending.

    Marshalling its large majority, the government easily survived an October 17 no-confidence vote by a 47-25 margin. The Prime Minister used the occasion to defend his government’s record, noting that inflation had been decreased, the tugrug stabilised, foreign currency reserves increased and a banking crisis halted.

    But by the end of the autumn session, rifts began to appear in Coalition forces. The State Budget for 1998 was approved in November. It forecast a deficit, and further spending cuts — notably to law-enforcement agencies — sparked grumbles among some MPs.

    In January, the government released its action plan for 1998. It vowed to stabilise the macroeconomy, cut government spending and boost private ownership in all sectors. The rate of privatisation was to be intensified, with an emphasis on selling off the state-owned banks. Even health and education were to be moved toward a “financed by the client” system.

    But the year also began with worrying economic signs, as the Asian economic crisis finally began to filter down to Mongolia. The price of copper, Mongolia’s largest foreign-currency earner, fell by nearly a quarter in the first four months of 1998. Prices for cashmere and gold, other major exports, also declined.

    At the beginning of 1998, differences within the Coalition intensified. A number of Democrats were dissatisfied with the system under which the Prime Minister and Cabinet were not parliamentarians but “experts” appointed from the outside. On January 15, after several weeks of wrangling, the State Ikh Hural ruled that, under the Mongolian Constitution, MPs could serve as Cabinet Ministers.

    A group of Coalition MPs, arguing that greater coordination was needed between Parliament and the government if the Democrats’ election promises were to be fulfilled, began to work for the change of the Enkhsaikhan Cabinet.

    Parliament resumed April 6 after a two-and-a-half month break during which fissures in the Coalition opened. An attempt in February by leaders of the National Democratic and Social Democratic Parties to merge the Coalition partners was rejected by party members.

    On March 27, the General Council of the Mongolian National Democratic Party called for the resignation of its own government. The move was led by Ts. Elbegdorj, the 35-year-old Deputy Speaker of the State Ikh Hural and parliamentary caucus leader of the MNDP — a natural Prime Minister in a government of MPs.

    The government had not acted in line with the wishes of Parliament and so should resign, he said.

    Prime Minister Enkhsaikhan complained that a faction in the party was trying to oust him. He was right.

    As the spring parliamentary session began, the intensity of demonstrations calling for the government’s resignation, which had gone on sporadically since the fall, increased.

    Enkhsaikhan bowed to the inevitable on April 17, a day after an extraordinary joint meeting of the ruling councils of the MNDP and MSDP, handing his resignation to President N. Bagabandi. It was approved by the State Ikh Hural on April 22, by a vote of 59-1. Ten MPs boycotted the session, saying the move was unconstitutional.

    The resignation divided Mongolians. Some felt it would speed up the pace of reform. Others saw it as a grab for power by a faction in the Coalition, or worried about the lack of experience of a Cabinet of MPs.

    The new Prime Minister, Ts. Elbegdorj, took office April 23, vowing to chart the same economic course as his predecessor, and to operate a more open and transparent government. Although he replaced a number of senior civil servants, he said he would not make changes to the structure of the nine government Ministries.

    He vowed to press forward with a busy spring session, in which a number of bills central to the government’s programme — including a new law on foreign investment and a long-awaited media law — were slated to be passed.

    But he immediately ran into trouble.

    Elbegdorj nominated his nine-member Cabinet April 27, but only five of the nominees received the approval of Parliament. The process came to border on farce, as nominee after nominee was shot down in the State Ikh Hural. The last Minister — Education Minister Ch. Saikhanbileg — was not approved until May 28. He was the fifth nominee put forward for the post.

    The local media began to call it the “bubblegum Cabinet” — average age 35.8. In place at last, some people began to worry about its lack of experience. Education Minister Saikhanbileg is only 29 years old, while Finance Minister B. Batbayar is a bio-physicist with no economics background.

    Then, at the beginning of June, the 25 Opposition MPs began a boycott in protest over the government-approved merger of the 18-month-old state-owned Sergeen Bosgoltyn (Reconstruction) Bank with the private Golomt Bank. The merger, which the government carried out with the backing of international financial institutions, was necessary, said the Finance Minister, because the Reconstruction Bank was insolvent, with 70 per cent of its Tg 11.2 billion (U.S. $13.7 million) in outstanding loans classed as unreliable.

    The Opposition labelled the merger a “conspiracy”, charging the government with driving the bank to its doom by racking up Tg 8.7 million ($10.5 million) in debts and pointing to links between the Golomt Bank and members of the National Democratic Party.

    The result was a Parliament paralysed for all of June. Key bills — including the foreign investment bill slated to be approved before a June 24-26 investors’ conference in Ulaanbaatar — languished.

    The crisis deepened when a large majority of al all-party task force appointed to investigate the merger rules that the move was improper.

    The President warned that if the impasse were not resolved soon, he would have no choice but to dissolve the State Ikh Hural and call an early election. Many observers consider an election likely when Parliament returns after the summer break.

    “Even if the government resigns or there is a new election, it will not mean that Mongolia will reverse its chosen path,” Prime Minister Elbegdorj told journalists on June 18. “The people have already made their choice.”

    2. Who’s Who in the Cabinet


    Prime Minister Ts. Elbegdorj, 35, is a former journalist and part-time poet. He studied journalism in the Ukraine and later worked for Ulaan Od (Red Star), the Defense Ministry newspaper. One of the founders of the Mongolian Democratic Movement, he was a key player in the 1900 protests. He was first elected to Parliament in [1996], becoming parliamentary leader of the Democratic Coalition.

    Finance Minister B. Batbayar, 44, is one of Mongolia’s best-known political figures, known to one and all as Baabar. A founding member of the Mongolian Social Democratic party, he played a key role in the democratic movement of the early 1990s. Trained as a bio-physicist in Mongolia and Poland, he worked as a scientific researcher from 1981 to 1991, was founding head of the Social Democrats from 1991 to 1994 and served as an independent journalist from 1994 until he was elected to Parliament in the 1996 general election.

    Foreign Minister R. Amarjargal, 37, trained as an economist at the National Economics Institute in Moscow. He worked for the Mongolian Trade Union Federation, as a university lecturer and rector of the Economics College in Ulaanbaatar. He was elected to Parliament in 1996 for the Mongolian national Democratic Party. He supports Manchester United Football Club.

    Minister of Nature and the Environment S. Bayartsogt, 31, studied economics at Moscow University before going into politics. He worked for the Revolutionary Youth Organisation between 1989 and 1990, and sat on the former assembly, the State Baga Hural, from 1990 to 1992. He lectured at the Political Education Academy from 1992 to 1994 and spent the next two years studying in Germany. He was elected to parliament in 1996.

    Justice Minister S. Batchuluun, 44, studied law at the Mongolian National University and worked as a lecturer at the Police Institute and as a senior civil servant for the Office of the Hural of People’s Deputies and the President’s Office. He was a member of the State Baga Hural from 1992 to 1994 and in 1994 was head of the MNDP’s Ulaanbaatar Council.

    Minister of Agriculture and Industry N. Altankhuyag, 40, is another bio-physicist, trained at the Mongolian National University. He lectured at the university for a decade from 1981 to 1991,was secretary of the Mongolian Social Democratic Party between 1990 and 1992 and in 1993-1994 was director of the Ene Odor company.

    Health and Social Security Minister Sh. Batbayar, 52, trained as a doctor at the Mongolian Medical University. After military service in 1964-67, he worked as a doctor at Zuunkharaa hospital in Selenge aimag, a lecturer at Darkhan Medical College and chief doctor at Darkhan city hospital.He held that post until he was elected to parliament in 1996 for the Mongolian Social Democratic Party.

    Minister of Infrastructure Development S. Zorig, 36, is another high-profile National Democrat MP, a Member of Parliament since 1990. A sociology graduate of Moscow Sate University, he led the Revolutionary Youth Organisation’s Ulaanbaatar wing from 1985 to 1986 and was a lecturer at the Mongolian National University between 1986 and 1989, obtaining a Masters degree from the university in 1990. He was a member of the State Baga Hural in 1990-1992 and has been a member of the State Ikh Hural since 1996.

    Defense Minister R. Odonbaatar, 37, studied economics and management at the Mongolian National University and in Novosibirsk, Russia. He has relevant job experience, having completed two years of military service between 1984 and 1986. He worked as an accountant and economist for several soum administrations in his native Khovsgol aimag and was head of the aimag branch of the MNDP from 1992 to 1994. He was elected to the State Ikh Hural in a 994 by-election.

    Minister of Enlightenment (Science, Technology, Education and Culture)Ch. Saikhanbileg, 29, is Mogolia’s youngest MP. He studied at Moscow’s Young Communist University and the Mongolian National University and has served on the executive of the Mongolian Youth Federation since 1991, rising to President — a position he still holds. He was elected to parliament for the MNDP in 1996.

    3. What’s on the Government’s plate?

    At the start of 1998, the government boasted that it had fulfilled 38 per cent of its Contract With Voters. But there is still a lot to do. 1998 was supposed to be the year that the government increased the pace of reform. Plans for the year included overhauls of all sectors of society, from education to the army.

    Stabilising the macroeconomy is the major goal, with the government setting a target of cutting both borrowing and spending, holding inflation below 20 per cent, keeping the exchange rate stable within five per cent and maintaining U.S. $80 million in foreign-currency reserves, 4.5 per cent real growth in the GDP, a budget deficit held to 8.6 per cent of GDP and a decline in budget revenues of less than 2.1 per cent.

    Privatisation is still the major pillar of the government’s plans, and the big state enterprises — including the Erdenet copper mine and the state-owned banks — are supposed to go on the block in 1998.

    On the industrial front, increased production of gold, minerals and oil is the key. Strive to keep unemployment to 6.5 per cent.

    On the social side, while cutting spending, the government vowed to improve the infrastructure and efficiency of fuel, water and electricity supplies, increase pensions in line with inflation, set a new minimum wage (a move that came into effect January 1) and create more jobs and services for disabled Mongolians and improve both food supply and food safety.

    At the time of printing key pieces of legislation, including the foreign investment law and the media law, were being held up by a boycott of Parliament by the opposition MPRP. The MPRP has refused to return to Parliament until the findings of an investigation into the merger of a government bank and the private Golomt Bank have been published.

    Creative Commons License

    This work is licensed under a
    Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.

    ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5311-1052.

    © David South Consulting 2026

  • Paper Citation For Southern Innovator Issue 1 

    Paper Citation For Southern Innovator Issue 1 

    Abady, Thadreina and Namun, Kingston (2016) “Web 2.0 distinct characteristics and implications for small businesses in Papua New Guinea,” Contemporary PNG Studies: DWU Research Journal Vol. 24 May 2016.

    Launched in 2011, Southern Innovator’s first issue on mobile phones and information technology proved highly influential, profiling the work of a new generation of innovators. It has been cited in books, papers and strategic plans.  

    Creative Commons License

    This work is licensed under a
    Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.

    ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5311-1052.

    © David South Consulting 2025